Welcome to Daniel's Blog

My blog was made for posting my reader responses for school. So if you are a random person who is not in my class, you won't be very impressed.

Friday, April 1, 2011

Reader Response for Dairy of a Wimpy Kid: The Ugly Truth

                     I am responding to Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Ugly Truth by Jeff Kinney.  I have read 217/217 pages.  The text is fiction. 
                   The main Characters are Greg Heffley (The protagonist), Rowley Jefferson, Manny Heffley, Rodrick Heffley and Mr. and Mrs. Heffley.  There are many other characters but most of them are just minor characters that are exclusive to various subplots.  The genre of this text is realistic fiction because it has many things that are drawn from the writer’s imagination but true to real life, such as a pre-teen going to middle school and kids feeling awkward about going through puberty.  The setting is in the present day, during the months of September and November.  The story takes place is in an unnamed town, Greg’s house and Greg’s school.  There are many little conflicts in the book but the main one is that Greg is started to through puberty and has to deal with the many changes that are going on with his life.  The theme of this book is dealing with change.  I think this is the theme because Greg needs to cope with the changes that are going on with his life, such as the puberty issue that I talked about before, becoming more mature as a person and accepting that he is not a little kid anymore.  Because this book doesn’t revolve around on central plot it is hard to choose a climax, but I think the climax is when Greg is at his Uncle Gary’s wedding and is going into his Grandmother’s room so she can have “The Talk” with him.  Like I said before, the protagonist is Greg Hefley.  It is hard to name an antagonist because this book is written as a diary and it doesn’t focus and the struggle between Greg and any other character.  In my opinion the characters that are best suited for the title of the antagonists are the teachers at Greg’s school who constantly make the student’s life hard.



Retell

          The title of this text gives me a different message than the actual text.  In the book the characters are going through puberty and have to deal with changes in their lives.  When I first read the title, it said to me that the main character would have to face the truth about himself.  This is further backed up by the fact that the cover features Greg sitting down and looking depressed.  I think that this is very misleading and shouldn’t happen often.   

What I want to remember about this book is the author’s style of writing.  Unlike traditional fictional novels, the author wrote this book as if he was really writing a diary.  He makes it seem like he is writing a biography of somebody’s life.  I think this is why his books are so popular, because he can connect to anybody, even if they don’t have a diary.  I this book was non-fiction then I would classify it under auto-biography.

To be honest, the character I dislike the most is theprotagonist, Greg Heffley.  I really don’t like his personality.  He constantly is being selfish, lazy and he is not one to admit his mistakes.  I’ll also admit that this is actually what gets me to read more of the book. That’s because his attitude adds humour to the book.  For example, when Greg was trying to get the maid to do most of his chores for him, she saw how lazy he was and made many notes to him that got her out of doing work.  It’s Greg’s attitude getting him into trouble that makes you always want to read more.  So while I dislike his personality, I also think it is the most appealing thing about this book.

Relate

                As compared to other text’s by Jeff Kinney that are in the Diary of a Wimpy Kid series, I think this book is the one with the most subplot’s that are relevant to the main plot.  Like I said before, this book has many subplots in it and one central plot that is referred to many times.  In the first four books there are no main plots.  The story is really driven by different little subplots and if they weren’t all in the same book, they could even become a daily comic strip in the newspaper.  That is why this book stands out from the rest.

At the end of the book, Rowley Jefferson and Greg Heffley make up and become friends again.  If I were Rowley I would not have forgiven him and become friends with him.  As I said before, Greg is selfish, lazy and thinks that he is always right.  Rowley always acted the opposite of Greg.  That made him very happy in life and he got very popular because he was his very nice, self.  In each book before this one Greg was always keeping him down and never let him do anything to his full potential.  In my life, many adults tell me to hang out with people who I can do my best with and Greg is far from being that.  That is why I would have done the opposite of what Rowley did at the end of the book.

This text makes me think about children taking on responsibility.  Many times when children grow older they have to learn to do things for themselves.  This happens to everyone I know and in the book Greg is learning about this.  At the beginning of the book Greg talks about how he always makes his mom do his laundry and letting her do everything around the house.  In the middle of the book Greg’s Mom decides that she is going to take some courses and the men of the family will have to start working around the house.  This was supposed to teach him to do things for himself and become a responsible person but he still was lazy.  A similar thing happened to me when my mom and dad starting leaving the house more and I had to start doing the dishes, and cleaning up after myself.  Unlike Greg, I actually became more responsible and learned independence.  Greg was still lazy after his experience and stayed that way until the very end of the book.  This also shows that me and Greg are very unlike each other and probably never will be alike.  



Reflect

I noticed that the author didn’t give us any information about the fight between Rowley and Greg.  At the beginning of the book, the narrator (Greg) explains that he and Rowley had a fight and they weren’t friends anymore.  Throughout the book this is frequently mentioned but there is no explanation of the cause of the fight or what happened during the fight.  In most books that I read, such as The Maze Runner which I did my last reader response on, there is an explanation of the events that occur immediately before the book.  Even if it doesn’t happen right away, there is always an explanation later in the book.  This is something that bothered me slightly, while I was reading the book.

I think that the illustrations really make this book a creative piece of writing.  In this and all the previous books, the main thing that attracts readers is the illustrations.  The author uses amateur pictures that a 10 year old could draw as the pictures.  This makes this book stand out from most as it uses humour to the story and it makes the reader feels as if they are reading a comic, not a novel.  This also shows that the author knows how to make it seem as if we are reading somebody’s diary.  I think this is also one of the main selling points for this novel.

If I could speak to the author I would ask him what his inspiration for writing these novels were.  Whenever somebody is thinking of an idea of a story there is always something that gives them the idea.  This book is written in diary format and from what I know; there have never been any past works of literature that are fictional biographies/diaries.  I do know that there have been biographies written but there have been none written in this format that has been released.  The author may have had past experiences that influenced Greg’s adventures and I would really like to know what his real reasons for writing this amazing series.

4 comments:

  1. Well, Daniel, as usual I thoroughly enjoyed reading your response. You have an excellent awareness of yourself as a reader and I love the variety of topics you select to comment on.

    I was so happy to see you divided up your 3 sections into separate paragraphs. It made it much more readable and better organized. I appreciate you taking my feedback and applying it!

    I agree with your point about the appeal of a diary-style narrative. There is a certain "privacy," or "secrecy," that surrounds diaries, and by reading someone else's, it feels like a special insight into the character's thoughts/voice.

    I also thought your comment about the difference between your personality and Greg's was interesting. You do sound very different. However, there is some fun/entertainment value to reading about people who are different from us. It's part of the "escape" that literature can offer us, don't you think?

    Last but not least, I thought your description of the narrative elements was AWESOME. You have done a great job identifying theme in this one. I like that you stretched your thinking a bit for the antagonist, when there was no single clear character in that role.

    WELL DONE, SIR! I admire the clarity of your writing, your mature voice, and the love of reading you exhibit!

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Aw, this was a really nice post. In concept I would like to put in writing like this moreover – taking time and actual effort to make an excellent article… however what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means appear to get one thing done. casino bonus

    ReplyDelete